It’s a bird, it’s a plane…no it’s Superman: making his return to the big screen this weekend in SUPERMAN. Directed by James Gunn of GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY fame, this reboot of the popular and iconic DC hero (and arguably the greatest superhero of all time), will be the fourth version of the Man of Steel to appear in feature-length films. Here now is the history of Superman on the big screen, sorted by the actors who played him.
The Christopher Reeve Era: 1978 – 1987
Superman got off to a magnificent start with this Richard Donner-directed masterpiece of fun, drama, and good old-fashioned heroics: SUPERMAN: THE MOVIE. The late great Christopher Reeve donned the cape and boots, and in a performance that has yet to be matched, gave Superman and Clark Kent humanity and heart. With an excellent cast that included Marlon Brando, Gene Hackman, Margo Kidder, Ned Beatty, Glenn Ford, Jackie Cooper, and Valerie Perrine…and a tremendous score by John Williams, SUPERMAN set a gold standard for superhero films that every comic-book film has been chasing. Reeve would reprise the role for the well-received SUPERMAN II in 1981, and the zany comedy SUPERMAN III (1983) alongside Richard Pryor. Reeve’s up-and-down run would end on a sour note, with the low-budget and ill-conceived SUPERMAN IV: THE QUEST FOR PEACE (1987)…one of the worst superhero films ever made.
The Brandon Routh Era: 2006
Superman would see success on television for many years, but he would be absent from the big screen for a long time, until X-MEN director Bryan Singer brought him back to Earth with SUPERMAN RETURNS in 2006. Brandon Routh played Clark Kent/Superman that served as a homage sequel to the Reeve films. Routh was joined by Kevin Spacey, Kate Bosworth, James Marsden, Frank Langella, and Parker Posey. SUPERMAN RETURNS delivered some genuine moments of stand-up-and-cheer and take-your-breath-away, but was met with mixed reviews and only earned enough to be the ninth highest grossing film of the year. Routh’s run as Superman would begin and end here.
The Henry Cavill Era: 2013 – 2021
After another long break from film, Superman returned in 2013 in the Zack Snyder-helmed MAN OF STEEL. Produced by THE DARK KNIGHT TRILOGY mastermind Christopher Nolan, MAN OF STEEL went for a grounded approach that worked in some places but fell on its face in others. Henry Cavill looked great in the suit, but was sadly asked to play the character as a miserable, unhappy shit. The cast was stacked (Amy Adams, Michael Shannon, Kevin Costner, Diane Lane, Laurence Fishburne, Russell Crowe), and Hans Zimmer delivered a thundering score, but MAN OF STEEL did not click with audiences…met with mixed reviews and finishing as the ninth-highest grossing film of the year.
Things did not improve for Cavill over his next appearances. Next came another Snyder mess: BATMAN V. SUPERMAN: DAWN OF JUSTICE in 2016 which felt like 54 different movies mashed together. Cavill was joined by Ben Affleck (Batman), and Gal Gadot (Wonder Woman), and was once again asked to play our beacon of hope as the most miserable person on the planet.
It is no spoiler to say that Cavill’s Superman would be killed at the end of DAWN OF JUSTICE, and Snyder and parent studio Warner Bros. would treat Cavill like yesterday’s news leading up to the super-messy JUSTICE LEAGUE (2017). Cavill was left out of the marketing as if audiences had no idea he would be coming back, and once he did return, it amounted to an extended cameo. JUSTICE LEAGUE would go through more than one recut until they thought they got it right, but not much improved.
The David Corenswet Era: 2025
After the SnyderVerse of DC heroes mercifully came to an end, the time had come to wipe the slate clean. Enter James Gunn of Marvel fame with a brand-new version, SUPERMAN. David Corenswet plays Supes, and he is joined by Rachel Brosnahan, Nicholas Hoult, Nathan Fillion, and Isabella Merced. The film follows Superman’s journey to come to terms with his alien heritage with his adapted human family.
*
SUPERMAN lands in theatres this weekend.